Thursday, June 26, 2008


D.C. gun laws struck down!


Alex said...

[this comment doesn't really belong here, but do any of us really belong anywhere?]

Not nearly as earth shaking, but perhaps of more practical importance for those of us who rarely cite constitutional decisions, the Supreme Court of Appeals of West Virginia ruled on Thursday that filing a "John Doe" complaint counts as a mistake under Rule 15(c).

This ruling, which the Court notes goes against the weight of federal interpretation of the federal rule counterpart, will permit later, amended complaints to relate back to the John Doe complaint and thus avoid potential statute of limitation problems. Of course, the plaintiff must have clean hands, and can't fail to investigate the identity of potential defendants.

WV amendment law already liberally allowed amendments, but still -- I think this is a pretty big deal. I've had to make 5-6 Rule 15 motions in the last year.
It would seem prudent (and not part of an unfair strategy) to include john doe defendants whenever there is the possibility of unknown defendants and a looming statute of limitations

Brian said...

Thanks much for this. I'm copying it to the main page.